5 Pet-Friendly Weed Killer Options for a Safe and Beautiful Yard

2017-08-29
5 Pet-Friendly Weed Killer Options for a Safe and Beautiful Yard

You may be tempted to resort to potent products when weeds become a losing battle. Unfortunately, many substances sold to combat pesky plants aren't pet-friendly weed killers. Even "eco-friendly" or natural herbicides are capable of causing injury when misused. Add a dog that likes to dig and roll in your lawn or garden, and you could risk harmful effects.

In fact, even just romping in the grass can pose a threat since your furry friends can pick up herbicides and other pesticides when walking through the yard. Those substances transfer to their paws and fur, which they may inadvertently ingest while grooming themselves.

So, are you doomed to a weedy yard if you have pets? Not necessarily. Some pet-friendly weed killers and lawn-care strategies can cut down on leafy invaders without threatening the health of your animals. Here's what you need to know to keep your pets safe while warding off weeds.

Pet-Friendly Weed Killers

Before you waste time, effort, and money on ineffective products or potentially harmful substances that put your pet at risk, evaluate your tolerance for weeds. Can you live with a light smattering of them? A few lawn weeds aren't problematic—as long as you work to keep the grass healthy, the unwanted plants aren't likely to get out of control. Also, mulching garden beds regularly will keep weeds from taking over ornamental plantings.

1. Weeding by Hand

The most effective way to eradicate lawn and garden weeds is by removing them by hand. It can be tedious work, but it's the best way to ensure you eliminate the plant's root. (Both harmful and non-harmful weed killers can leave roots behind to regenerate; for example, dandelions have long roots.)

Many handy weeding tools on the market speed up the process, so if your problem is sporadic weeds, this is a fairly surefire way to handle them without using potentially harmful substances. Hand-weeding is best thought of as an ongoing practice, and it's most effective when begun in spring. In garden beds, you can eradicate weed seedlings by hoeing.

The other primary benefit of weeding by hand is that you can be selective—only the plants you want to kill will be affected. Unfortunately, most environmentally friendly herbicides and weed-killing methods aren't picky; they'll kill or damage any plant they touch.

2. Smothering Weeds

Like any plant, weeds need sunlight to thrive. So if you block their access to light, they'll die. The easiest way to suffocate them is to lay down a thick layer (3 to 5 inches) of organic mulch, such as wood chips or pine needles. (Avoid cocoa mulch, which is toxic to dogs if eaten.). The mulch allows water and air through but keeps sunlight out. As a result, your soil will stay healthy; small weeds and seeds hidden under the mulch won't survive.

When creating a new garden, you can lay opaque plastic sheeting, layers of cardboard, or carpet scraps over the area where you want to kill all plants. Leave the layers in place for about six weeks during the growing season to smother weeds effectively. Avoid tilling the soil afterward to prevent buried weed seeds from being brought to the soil surface, where they can more easily germinate.

3. Applying Horticultural Vinegar

In its concentrated form, vinegar can kill young, tender plants. Keep in mind that horticultural vinegar is a non-selective killer, meaning it will damage any plant it touches. Also, be aware that it's a strong acid, so avoid contact with your skin, eyes, or nose. (Make sure to wear gardening gloves!) Read and follow label directions carefully, and keep your pets off of treated areas until the vinegar dries.

This method is especially effective for cracks in sidewalks or driveways. But don't be discouraged if the first application doesn't do the job: Since horticultural vinegar only damages the plant tissue it touches, established weeds may not die until you've sprayed them a few times.

Using horticultural vinegar may sound like a money-saving idea, but it isn't. Concentrated vinegar is a pet-friendly weed killer that can be as expensive as standard commercial herbicides.

4. Burning or Boiling Weeds

If occasional weeds are your problem—think pesky sprouts that pop up between patio pavers or cracks in the driveway— extreme heat is a pet-friendly weed killer. Try burning them with a welding torch or scalding them with boiling water. Just be careful not to injure yourself in the process! Note that these methods won't kill the roots of established weeds and may have to be repeated several times over the summer.

5. Other Natural or Organic Pet-Friendly Weed Killers

Several products sold in stores use concentrated essential oils, soaps, or other natural ingredients. Very few of them are selective weed killers, so they'll damage anything they touch; they also have different levels of effectiveness.

Corn gluten meal showed initial promise as a pre-emergent herbicide. Still, there are downsides: The application timing (in spring before weeds emerge) is critical since it doesn't affect established weeds. The upshot is that it's a pet-safe weed killer.

Some products work but take days to show results, and many require repeated applications. Read and follow label directions carefully, don't expect instant or permanent results, and keep pets away from newly-treated areas according to the product's instructions. Although a product may claim to be made of natural ingredients, it can still potentially irritate your skin, eyes, or nose.

What Not to Use

Some household products suggested for killing weeds, such as salt, borax, or sugar, are ineffective and can damage the soil. For example, borax will inhibit the growth of desirable plants. Salt can likewise cause a severe imbalance in soil chemistry. Sugar attracts pests of all kinds, and it might even entice your pets or wildlife to eat something they shouldn't.

Rethink Your Garden's Design

If you want your lawn and garden to be completely weed-free, you'll need to think carefully about what methods or materials to use. You may want to consider options for your garden's design to reduce the need for weeding.

A naturalistic plan will camouflage weeds since it presents a less regimented look than a more planned layout. Some gardeners choose to revert to a wildflower garden, allowing plants to grow naturally and attracting more pollinators and birds to their outdoor space. Rock gardens, container gardens, and adding a deck instead of a patio are all traditional lawn and garden options that will reduce the need to use even pet-friendly weed killers or chemicals to keep your yard looking the way you'd like it to.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Which animals are good for weed control?

    The best animals to have in your yard for weed control are goats, horses, and cows. They'll eat weeds while grazing on grass. Keep them away from vegetable gardens and other plants, though. They'll eat those too.

  • Are weeds toxic to pets?

    Some weeds are toxic to pets, including jimsonweed, thorn apple, milkweed, and others. Milkweed is also toxic to humans.

Sources
Better Homes & Gardens is committed to using high-quality, reputable sources—including peer-reviewed studies—to support the facts in our articles. Read about our editorial policies and standards to learn more about how we fact check our content for accuracy.
  1. "Cocoa Bean Mulch Can Poison Dogs." National Capital Poison Center

  2. Weed-Eating Biomachines. University of California (Agriculture and Natural Resources), 2015

  3. What Weeds are Poisonous to Dogs? Pet Poison Helpline

  4. "Milkweed Plant Can Cause Serious Poisoning." National Capital Poison Center

Related Article

How to Propagate Orchids Successfully, Depending on Type

How to Propagate Orchids Successfully, Depending on Type

Learn the best techniques for propagating orchids that are monopodial or sympodial. Get essential tips and expert advice to propagate orchids by keiki or division.
How to Grow and Care for Nerve Plant

How to Grow and Care for Nerve Plant

Want to grow a nerve plant? Learn how to care for these tropical houseplants, where to grow them in your home, common pests, and different types to choose from.
How to Grow and Care for Living Stones

How to Grow and Care for Living Stones

Find out how to grow living stones, unique miniature succulents that look like pebbles. This guide covers how to care for living stone plants, including watering them just right to keep them thriving.
8 Begonia Houseplant Care Tips to Keep Your Plants Thriving

8 Begonia Houseplant Care Tips to Keep Your Plants Thriving

Find out how to care for begonia houseplants with these tips on the best types to grow, lighting, watering, fertilizer, and more.
11 Bathroom Plants That Thrive in Humidity

11 Bathroom Plants That Thrive in Humidity

Add some life to your home with these 11 high humidity bathroom plants. Dim lighting and a moist environment are exactly what they need to flourish.
How to Stop Woodpeckers from Pecking Your House

How to Stop Woodpeckers from Pecking Your House

Are woodpeckers pecking your siding? Learn why they’re making a racket and more importantly, how to get them to stop.
Discover Your Garden Personality to Create Your Perfect Outdoor Space

Discover Your Garden Personality to Create Your Perfect Outdoor Space

Garden designer Ryan McEnaney shares his insights and tips on finding your outside style based on your garden personality.
Grow Perfect Tomatoes with This PVC Trellis

Grow Perfect Tomatoes with This PVC Trellis

Protect your homegrown produce and learn how to make an arbor made with PVC pipes. This easy project is much less expensive than store-bought options!
13 Colorful Nectar Plants for Pollinators

13 Colorful Nectar Plants for Pollinators

Create a gorgeous, pollinator-friendly garden by including these nectar-rich plants.
How to Make a Tomato Cage Plant Stand

How to Make a Tomato Cage Plant Stand

Repurpose a tomato cage to create a tall plant stand perfect for a front stoop container garden. Add rustic flair with rope-wrapped rows.
How to Plant and Grow Skeleton Flower

How to Plant and Grow Skeleton Flower

Skeleton flower is a unique and rare plant with petals that look clear when wet. This guide explains how to grow these unique and rare flowers, which do best in dappled light and consistently moist soil.
How to Plant and Grow Ranunculus

How to Plant and Grow Ranunculus

Ranunculus are favorite flowers for weddings, arrangements, and gardens. Here's how to plant and grow ranunculus.
How to Grow Roses from Cuttings of Your Favorite Varieties in 10 Simple Steps

How to Grow Roses from Cuttings of Your Favorite Varieties in 10 Simple Steps

In only a few simple steps, you can learn how to grow roses from cuttings to make your garden extra gorgeous.
How to Propagate Clematis from Cuttings and Layering

How to Propagate Clematis from Cuttings and Layering

Learn how to propagate clematis successfully with this step-by-step guide on two different techniques.
Dress Up Your Home with This Foolproof Foundation Garden Plan

Dress Up Your Home with This Foolproof Foundation Garden Plan

Create a welcoming look for your home with this easy-care combination of foundation plantings that will look great around the foundation of your home.
When and How to Harvest Spinach at Its Peak

When and How to Harvest Spinach at Its Peak

Learn how to harvest spinach microgreens, baby leaves, and mature greens with these simple tips.
The Plant Food That Saved My Roses Is Almost  at My Local Flower Shop, but It’s  at Amazon Right Now

The Plant Food That Saved My Roses Is Almost at My Local Flower Shop, but It’s at Amazon Right Now

One writer’s Knock Out roses were looking worse for wear, and now, thanks to an Instagram recommendation for a Amazon product, these blooms are thriving. Shop the Osmocote Smart-Release Plant Food on sale for 25 percent off.
How to Use Fertilizer for Plants According to Experts

How to Use Fertilizer for Plants According to Experts

Get expert tips on fertilizing plants, including the best formulation for both houseplants and garden plants, as well as how frequently you should feed them.
30 Facts About Plants You Didn't Know Until Now

30 Facts About Plants You Didn't Know Until Now

Did you know you can cut onions without crying? Here are some fun and interesting facts about plants.
Ladybug vs. Asian Lady Beetle: How to Tell the Good Bug from the Bad Bug

Ladybug vs. Asian Lady Beetle: How to Tell the Good Bug from the Bad Bug

A ladybug and an Asian lady beetle look similar, but one type helps control unwanted insects in the garden while the other is a pest itself. Here's how to tell these similar-looking bugs apart.